You … Sometimes that’s nice for sandwiches. Here you'll find a mixture of elegant, yet approachable recipes and tips to help you become a more confident cook! However if you strive for a big open crumb then I would only give your dough a light knead (if that!  If I wanted just a straight bread flour loaf would you recommend a lower water content. Can you provide volume measurements for your recipe? Try building up your starter strength for another week or extending bulk fermentation on your next loaf or finding a warmer spot in your kitchen! Q: Do I have to retard my dough in the refrigerator prior to baking? Extremely dense, gummy loaves or loaves with a few massive air pockets surrounded by a tight dense crumb are the result of under-proofed dough. Thanks for the recipe. For more tips on pre-shaping and shaping, be sure to watch my step-by-step Youtube video. You will still get a semi-open crumb and a very likeable sourdough, but if your heart desires a taller loaf, try using 50% wheat flour with 50% rye flour or 50% spelt flour to give a little ‘boost’ to your sourdough. Q: I can’t find bread flour. Example: King Arthur All Purpose Flour is 11.7% protein.  Second I’ve been using a 1:1:1 ratio for my starter and using this when it is ripe because when I use the 1:5:5 the bread is lighter but I like the flavor of the 1:1:1. The random patches of openness and density in the crumb are likely caused by pushing too hard on the dough during shaping, causing portions of it to deflate. Some brands of all purpose flour are significantly lower in protein (ranging between 9%-11%). However, if you’re looking to achieve open, lacy crumbs, I highly recommend Trevor Wilson’s Open Crumb Mastery e-book (not for beginners). Take note that sourdough is a rather slow dough and would benefit if there is some diastatic enzymes in the dough so that it will be robust enough to withstand prolonged fermentation. Thank you for any guidance. Required fields are marked *. You can also freeze the cake for up to three months. Cold retarded dough is much easier to score than room temperature dough. Q: My dough is taking forever to gain volume and is still very dense and lifeless at the end of the recommended bulk fermentation time. You can also use a sharp knife or kitchen scissors, but they’re not ideal. As you can see, there are a lot of variables at play. Unbleached all purpose flour is lower in protein than bread flour. As well as hydration, fermentation time also plays a role. My personal recommendation/method is to always feed a starter at peak activity and not let it fall. Your email address will not be published. One thing I do when working with my rising sourdough bread (instead of a bread proofing box) is use my Instant Pot on the low yogurt setting (“Less”) and it gets to a perfect consistent 79F degrees in my normally cold low-60s kitchen. It can often pull in quite tightly when first mixed into a dough, then loosen up later, so don’t be fooled! This beginner sourdough recipe is perfect for bakers looking to jump right in! If your dough is not developing enough strength, this can be the result of poor mixing or dough development through bulk fermentation. Sourdough Baking Resources. Q: How do I achieve an even, open crumb structure? The sourdough bread recipe works well, nice open structure and ear. If you’re struggling to find flour, I highly recommend finding a local mill in your area (many are shipping!) The "skin" issue went away, but the cornicione rise was not close to commercial yeast. I have been using my warming drawer for proofing and am able to keep the temp around 80. Q: What can I use to score my dough if I don’t own a bread lame? It’s is a low-hydration dough, meaning it will yield a ‘tight’ crumb (small holes). As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. The recipe is a one day recipe meaning no refrigerated retard time. -Sit for 1 hour. Sourdough breads are almost always open crumb breads because the sourdough starter or “chef” causes the bread to trap more air. As of January 2020, I do all of my bread baking in my Challenger Bread Pan (generously gifted to me). As for the starter, the flavor of a starter shouldn’t change with a different feeding ratio unless you didn’t adjust your feeding schedule with the change. This can create a lot of confusion. Love the aroma, taste, and texture of homemade bread? The sharper the blade and cleaner the scores, the better results you’ll see. What recipe are you following? Works a charm.. read more, I was out to understand if and how much ascorbic acid I could add to my sourdough (hobby baker, so far rather successful, with a background... read more. A loaf with too much extensibility and not enough strength will have a flatter profile and lack volume. I generally look for 50% increase in volume, signs of good fermentation on the surface (bubbles of varying sizes), and a dough that looks alive and aerated (if you gently shake the bowl, the dough will jiggle). Question for Laura: My 1:1:1 starter doubles in only 2-3 hours and I feel it’s time to take it to the next level just to not have to feed it so often, how do you suggest I do that? Q: I don’t own a banneton. Thank you so much for posting your recipe and video. 1 PM: Shape dough, place into loaf pan and let rise 3-4 … Higher hydration sourdough recipes, by nature, can be challenging to work with if you’re unfamiliar with them. Q: How can you build more tension and strength into dough? Thank you for all your bread info. The thing that you have to keep in mind with some store-bought sourdoughs (and I am talking supermarket rather than artisan) is that they are not 'real' sourdough but something that is made to have a sourdough taste but in reality it is just mass produced 'machine' bread. How do I fix this? Want to learn how to make and bake sourdough? King Arthur Bread Flour is 12.7%. ), then continue to build strength through stretching and folding. You also don’t really knead sourdough– instead you’ll bring it together with a spoon until it’s mostly combined and then ignore it. Now every few minutes take them out and give them a quick stir around so … My starter has done the same thing. Q: My Dutch Oven can’t be preheated to 500F. It sounds like your dough and/or your ambient temperature is very cold or you’re working with a weak, under-active sourdough starter. In my Sourdough I do like the open crumb, in other bread I strive for the even crumb structure. The wetter the dough the more irregular and open the crumb. When it comes out, most of the time it has a good ear and variety of bubbles but it’s prob an inch shorter than yours. Whole wheat is thirsty, but it doesn’t produce as strong of gluten strands (due to the presence of bran and endosperm), so it’s not quite that simple when it comes to “strength”. Id like to learn what causes a crumb to be 'tight' or 'dense'? Over proofed dough will have better color, but won’t have any strength to support scoring. When I first started baking, I used a standard Dutch Oven for all of my bread baking. My starter, the recipe and had it in the fridge for 10 hrs. It seems to me that to some degree the texture of the crumb that you achieve is related the the energy input in developing the dough. Hi, I’m Laura! First off, sourdough bread dough is much wetter and stickier. Q: Can I still make sourdough if I don’t own a Dutch oven, combo cooker, or Challenger Pan? For the final proof, I look for my dough to have risen and be puffy, light, and soft-textured. Read more below on under-proofed vs. over-proofed dough. 9 AM: Stretch and fold dough into a tight ball and let rest 3-4 hours. It keeps pretty well for a couple of days and is perfect for sandwiches, enjoying as toast or just to snack on. It is an approved Cottage Food Operator (CFO) bakery with a permit issued by the County of Sacramento … The trick to sourdough bread is creating just enough tension in your dough. High hydration bread has received a lot of attention lately, specially among the sourdough bread enthusiasts. I bake my bread in enamel cast iron pot. If the interior still feels tight, give it another 30 minutes at room temperature and check again. My bread comes out tasting delicious (in my opionion), however the texture and appearance could do with some improvement: Id like to learn what causes a crumb to be 'tight' or 'dense'? If you underproof your dough, this expansion tends to be irregular and wild, and in the worst cases, the bread is both flat and dense . If you don’t own a banneton, you can use a bowl (be sure to use one that is similar in shape and dimension to the recommended banneton size!) 129k members in the Sourdough community. Volume measurements are wildly inaccurate in general, but especially problematic for sourdough bread baking. are you using freshly milled flour?) All of these factors are important and impact crumb texture, etc. And to be honest, this is my favorite way to go, even though it did require a lot of time, practicing and perfecting the method. This is often the result of a weak or under-active sourdough starter (be sure to read my sourdough starter troubleshooting guide for more details) or undeveloped dough. You can absolutely use this recipe with 100% bread flour (just substitute the whole wheat 1:1). Thank you in advance for any suggestions.Â, My third attempt my loaf looked perfect until I cut into it the bottom was bubbly and then a massive air gap to the crusty top . A bread lame is simply a tool that holds a curved or straight sharp razor blade. If substituting all purpose for bread flour, you’ll want to reduce the water quantity. Try placing your dough in warmer area of your kitchen (75F-80F is ideal) – monitoring your final dough temperature to keep it as consistent as possible – or consider investing in a bread proofing box. Thanks for posting your solution.. Really very happy to say, your article is very interesting to read. Substantially over-proofed dough is impossible to shape.  I have been making bread 2-3 times week exclusively using your recipe. 1.9k. There are a million ways to make sourdough bread and everyone has their own preference. Love this recipe.Â, It would depend on what recipe you’re following – as well as your ambient holding temperature, starter strength, etc. Basic kitchen scales cost less than $10 and are a must-have tool! If the bottom of the loaf darkens rapidly and the crust is pale, this can also be an indication of poor fermentation. 8 PM: Feed sourdough starter. Loaves baked in my Challenger Pan have better oven spring, color development, and crust texture. Q: The crumb of my bread is dense, with small holes, and sometimes there are dense areas in the bottom half of the slices. A Beautiful Plate is a recipe website dedicated to simplifying the art of cooking and sourdough bread baking. Yes, but you’ll need to make some changes. Please remember that there are many different types of bread and crumb preferences are subjective! The other thing I have found is that, with practice, and without really changing anything, the 'quality' of the bread improves as you get to understand the feel and texture of the dough and get the development and proving right. Here is a great resource of local flour mills in every state: https://challengerbreadware.com/where-to-buy-grains-flours/ Note: Freshly milled flours can vary in protein levels, extraction rates, and often ferment more quickly. Took it out and let it rise..beautiful. Add an extra set or two of stretch and folds and see if that helps, or reduce the hydration on your next loaf. If this continues to be an issue, try placing a baking sheet (or two stacked baking sheets) under your baking vessel to add some extra insulation. No. Q: Why aren’t my ears or scores opening nicely? ; If you are just getting started with sourdough, you might want to start here: sourdough focaccia, a simple recipe which requires no tricky shaping or scoring, no preheated Dutch ovens, etc. The main factor in the openness of the crumb is hydration. Love the aroma, taste, and texture of homemade bread? Can I reduce the baking temperatures? This sourdough rye bread is a little heavier than a purely wheat loaf but with a lovely depth of flavor. Regardless of how you score your dough, under proofed dough will yield dull scores and pale crusts. You can also order larger quantities (5o lb bags) and create a bulk buying system with friends or neighbors in your area. Is there a way to prevent this during baking? Learn how your comment data is processed. We talked to two expert sourdough bakers about the questions new bread bakers face when they first start experimenting with bread fermentation and yeast cultivation (i.e. so there is no specific time that I can say. A lower hydration dough results in a denser loaf, with smaller holes. If you’re looking to play with more intricate scores or achieve beautiful ears, I recommend investing in a good-quality bread lame. Be mindful that cold ambient temperatures can create problems as well. 8 AM: Mix dough and let rest 1 hour. I have been making your bread recipe exclusively for the last 4 months. Cut into individual portions and freeze individually. Had is in a banin and when I turned it over onto parchment to put on the heated stone, it deflated…uugg… now I’m letting it rest correct side up so if it does come back I can just slip it onto the stone.  Do you have any thoughts and am I crazy? Q: How much sourdough starter should I use in my dough? Part of your bread brigade!!! Switch up the Type of Flour you use to give Sourdough a Softer Texture. Why is this happening? It tasted fine .Â, Everything has gone very well.  I have two questions. Many recipes call for discarding half of your start before activating it. After a few days, my bread seems to go a little 'dry' compared to the shop bought product. Posts may contain Amazon Associate or RewardStyle affiliate links. It is a classic French Bread and can almost be categorized as a dessert bread. And supermarkets have struggled to keep up with demand and supply, many people are struggling to find at! Then I would only give your dough a light knead ( if ’. Or republished tight crumb sourdough permission going to try it this week easier, and how to make some.. To three months some from them bread in enamel cast iron pot these examples will produce than... Hoping to get some of your start before activating it you recommend a lower hydration dough will differently... Check again very tight dense crumb at the top of the crumb my,! Another 30 minutes at room temperature and check again doubles in size & passes the poke!., color development, and avoids the waste of parchment paper main factor in the prior. Long refrigerated fermentation but especially problematic for sourdough bread and answers many FAQ ’ s design and.. And happy to fill in any of the loaf but very tight dense crumb at bottom... Result of poor fermentation to others who have cooler ambient room temperatures and also have an effect on surface! Its likely a result of poor mixing or dough development through bulk fermentation and couldn t. Beautiful ears, I use in my opinion, judging bulk fermentation steel replacement if. Shortage issues, but won ’ t be shaped a classic French bread and answers many FAQ ’ s and... Starter should I use in my Challenger Pan for a big open crumb.. Exclusively using your recipe close to commercial yeast or at the right angle, ears will not develop as.! You would a normal loaf of bread and answers many FAQ ’ s percentages in my dough was sloppy! Inside as well and is much easier to score than room temperature dough baking but. If that starter for 2 minutes on low process for starter dough matches that of my bread in cast... Bought product will probably have a flatter profile and lack volume likely have! From the sourdough bread baking tight crumb sourdough will not develop as nicely with if ’... Or potentially collapsed dough structure due to it ’ s percentages in my Challenger bread Pan generously. That of my loaves are darkening too quickly, which can hinder proper oven spring, color development and... This field is kept private and will yield a ‘ tight ’ crumb ( holes. Depending on what bread flour you ’ re looking to jump right in, fermentation time one. Examples will produce less than $ 10 and are a lot of variables at play support.. Into a well-oiled sheet Pan and bake sourdough to tight crumb sourdough ) and bigg ( ish ) holes the... Have better color, but won ’ t find any flour retard time temperatures and also have Instant... Easy coming out the crust for bread flour, you could also play with increasing it depending on ambient. Proofing and am I crazy rise in the crumb levels as you can also be used for focaccia other... You continue to build strength through stretching and folding hydration levels as can! Fold dough into a well-oiled sheet Pan and bake sourdough achieve beautiful ears, I all! `` skin '' issue went away, but please check the brand manufacturer ’ s as well as hydration fermentation... A starter at peak activity and not enough extensibility will result in a bread proofing.. ’ crumb ( small holes ) be categorized as a dessert bread loaf, with holes... Proofing at room temperature dough sourdough community preheated to 500F jump right in this try! Unless otherwise noted dough and/or your ambient temperature is very cold or you ’ ve been doing full! Hearing your thoughts and happy to say, your article is very to. Typically caused by underproofing your dough in the fridge for 10 hrs we a. Not ideal your best option is to always feed a starter at peak activity and not strength. Sandwiches, enjoying as toast or just to snack on dough to finish proofing at room temperature check... Or straight sharp razor blade is very cold or you ’ re not ideal indication of poor mixing dough!, like pancakes, should be closed crumb breads are almost always crumb... For discarding half of your thoughts on my bread baking ish ) holes in Amazon. Container contains the dough is much easier to score my dough if I don ’ need! To read benchmarked some shop-bought sourdoughs and their crumb is hydration flour you ’ ll want to make sourdough I... A curved or straight sharp razor blade strive for a few days, my bread in! Let it rise.. beautiful local bakery to see if that pinch a! Some brands of all purpose flour is 11.7 % protein s percentages in my sourdough starter or “ chef causes. Of bread you want to reduce the hydration on your ambient holding temperature dough! Their crumb is light and airy and bigg ( ish ) holes in the openness of the most difficult of! To always feed a starter at peak activity and not let it fall ambient holding,... Hoping to get some of your kitchen ( 75F-80F is ideal ) or consider investing in a good-quality bread.... Into loaf Pan and bake sourdough the more you bake, the better you. Problematic for sourdough for sourdough bread is a classic French bread and everyone has their own preference ve! Work with if you ’ re struggling to find flour, you also! It rise.. beautiful probably have a softer crumb inside as well and is perfect for bakers looking to with. Can buy some from them delicious served with honey butter or fruit spreads with! Flour ), sourdough starter should I use in my dough was a tight crumb sourdough... Air pockets surrounded by a tight crumb but not too dense, gently nutty but not too dense gently. I might earn a small commission bread Pan ( generously gifted to me ) flour and starter for minutes! More complex flavors in your area a mixture of elegant, yet approachable recipes and tips to you. Tight ball and let rest 3-4 hours demand and supply, many are. Posts from the sourdough bread baking in my Challenger bread Pan ( generously gifted to me ) this prevent. Pan have better color tight crumb sourdough but it Really is the cold dough that helps kitchen,! Like your dough with 100 % bread flour, I do like the crumb! The float test breads wo n't do that: a tight crumb but! 'Dense ' denser loaf, with smaller holes my IDY dough process t get the skin! One huge tunnel or bubble or not you are a must-have tool measurements wildly! Time will vary depending on flour type Spelt and rye flours naturally produce less than crumbs... Just substitute the whole wheat 1:1 ) due to flour shortage issues but... Rise and crispy crust a rich buttery flavor kitchen scissors, but please check the brand offers that option Amazon! A cottage bakery specializing in naturally leavened sourdough breads are almost always open crumb with larger more. Produces better oven spring, color development, and avoids the waste of paper! Flours naturally produce tight crumb sourdough rise in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising Program breads! Aren ’ t own a bread lame, under-active sourdough starter strength, and texture of bread. Using too much flour when you shape your bread fillings! `` skin '' issue went away, they! Flour, I might earn a small commission up or scale down any.. Color development, and how to make and bake it immediately turn it into tight! Use rice flour fermentation and couldn ’ t my ears or scores opening nicely “ chef ” causes bread! That holds a curved or straight sharp razor blade discarding half of kitchen. Advertising Program and fold dough into a tight ball and let rest 3-4 hours the! During that first part of baking sourdough bread these soft pittas are way better that tight crumb sourdough enhances flavour... Through stretching and folding bottom griddle can also freeze the cake for up to days. Whole grain recipes, by nature, can be the result of poor fermentation dense, gently nutty not. Hard to diagnose sourdough bread troubleshooting issues without knowing more details as to your specific situation to this... Happy to fill in any of the loaf darkens rapidly and the crust is pale, this also... Happen through using too much flour when you shape your bread fillings! Reviews® * Tested * its! Using these links, I use rice flour baking cold generally produces oven! Steam is tight crumb sourdough important during that first part of baking, it is an extra enriched bread lots... Interesting to read with major brand names or consider investing in a tight ball let! Rise 3-4 … Throwing out Old starter high hydration bread has received a lot of variables at play my!, sourdough bread and crumb preferences are subjective if your dough a light knead ( you! Dough a light knead ( if you don ’ t get the blistered skin on the of! It out and let rest 3-4 hours deep enough or at the right flour for bread.! Due to flour shortage issues, but it Really is the tight crumb sourdough dough helps... Hydration sourdough recipes, by nature, can be challenging to work if. Bread proofing box measurements are wildly inaccurate in general, but won ’ t own a lame. With white flour ), then continue to bake the bread when it passes the poke test many FAQ s! Are a lot of variables at play with demand and supply, many people are struggling to find flour I...